《八面威风》全部影评 (2篇)

Quotes

2026-07-212026-07-21
Eddie Cicotte: I always figured it was talent made a man big, you know, if I was the best at something. I mean, we're the guys they come to see. ... +

Eddie Cicotte: I always figured it was talent made a man big, you know, if I was the best at something. I mean, we're the guys they come to see. Without us, there ain't a ballgame. Yeah, but look at who's holding the money and look at who's facing a jail cell. Talent don't mean nothing. And where's Comiskey and Sullivan, Attell, Rothstein? Out in the back room cutting up profits, that's where. That's the damn conspiracy.
Buck Weaver: You get out there, and the stands are full and everybody's cheerin'. It's like everybody in the world come to see you. And inside of that there's the players, they're yakkin' it up. The pitcher throws and you look for that pill... suddenly there's nothing else in the ballpark but you and it. Sometimes, when you feel right, there's a groove there, and the bat just eases into it and meets that ball. When the bat meets that ball and you feel that ball just give, you know it's going to go a long way. Damn, if you don't feel like you're going to live forever.
[Some New Jersey fans are arguing on whether a Hoboken outfielder is Joe Jackson (the outfielder is, in fact, Shoeless Joe)]
New Jersey Fan #1: You ever see him play?
New Jersey Fan #2: Yeah, I saw pictures.
New Jersey Fan #1: Pictures
[scoffs]
Buck Weaver: I saw him play.
New Jersey Fan #1: Yeah? What do you think?
Buck Weaver: He was the best. Run, hit, throw... he was the best.
New Jersey Fan #1: So what do you think? Is it him?
Buck Weaver: Nah. Those fellas are all gone now.

真实丑闻,平淡呈现——《八面威风》为何没拍出震撼感

2026-07-212026-07-21
豆瓣6.7分,不足千人评价——这个数字已经说明一切。作为一部改编自美国棒球史上最大丑闻的影片,《八面威风》按理说应该让人看得血脉贲张或怒不可遏,结果呢?专业评价一针见血:“戏剧张力不足,情感表达偏弱,没能让丑闻本身发挥出应有的震撼力量。” 问题出在哪?导演约翰·塞尔斯过于追求还原事件本身,把电影拍成... +
豆瓣6.7分,不足千人评价——这个数字已经说明一切。作为一部改编自美国棒球史上最大丑闻的影片,《八面威风》按理说应该让人看得血脉贲张或怒不可遏,结果呢?专业评价一针见血:“戏剧张力不足,情感表达偏弱,没能让丑闻本身发挥出应有的震撼力量。” 问题出在哪?导演约翰·塞尔斯过于追求还原事件本身,把电影拍成了平铺直叙的“事件重现”。你看那群球员,从被收买到比赛放水,从内心挣扎到最终认罪,所有情节都按时间线老老实实走了一遍,却几乎没在人物心理上多花笔墨。观众只知道他们缺钱、他们干了、他们被抓了,但为什么他们敢冒天下之大不韪?除了钱,还有什么?影片没深入。于是整部电影就像一杯温吞水,你清楚每件事的来龙去脉,却始终无法真正共情。观众反馈也印证了这点:“叙事偏平淡,戏剧冲突较弱,缺乏足够的感染力。”对棒球迷来说,比赛场面和专业细节或许看得过瘾,但对普通观众而言,这就是一部节奏缓慢、情绪波澜不惊的历史记录片。导演自己在片中客串了体育记者林拉德纳,这个彩蛋挺有意思,却改变不了电影整体缺乏高潮的事实。不是说还原历史有错,但电影不是新闻简报。同题材的《芝加哥》就算歌舞升平,至少让观众记住了那种纸醉金迷下的腐败。《八面威风》呢?看完只会记住查利·辛年轻时挺帅——可这不是我们想记住的。如果导演能聚焦于某一个球员的内心挣扎,或者多展现一些赌徒与球员的暗箱操作细节,哪怕虚构一点冲突,都比现在这个四平八稳的版本强。总之,这部电影适合补全历史知识,但别指望获得什么震撼体验。评分6.7,不多不少,恰好说明它及格了,但也仅仅是及格。
八面威风海报
片名:八面威风
类型:剧情,历史,运动
地区:美国
语言:英语
片长:119分钟
上映:1988-09-02

电影

电视剧

动漫